Logo

/// The King's Speech - cut with Avid or Final Cut?

The King's Speech - cut with Avid or Final Cut?




News reporting slashCAM:
Februar 2011

Hier geht es zur Newsmeldung with Link and Bildern auf den slashCAM Magazine-Seiten




Reply Jott:

A feature film consists almost exclusively of hard cuts - and that creates really any NLE. To discuss which film with which product was cut - or even to advertise it - is profoundly ridiculous.


Reply wenzx:

Also an issue which I find very interesting especially since there are a few more times with someone actually Programs SpeedEdit of NewTek has worked? I would be interested if burning it with can hold the dogmatic A products with?


Reply emu:

"Jott" wrote:
A feature film consists almost exclusively of hard cuts - and that creates really any NLE. To discuss which film with which product was cut - or even to advertise it - is profoundly ridiculous.


Well, so the argument can be so but can not synonymous are: especially for large productions play so synonymous terms such as integration into the production cycle (particularly synonymous interaction with the Music / Sound department) and above all the media management is a great role and exactly it's for very different.

The type of Aperture is more probably of secondary importance, otherwise you could cut synonymous with Quicktime - it can synonymous hard cuts.


Reply Axel:

"Emu" wrote:
... especially for large productions play so synonymous terms such as integration into the production cycle (in particular the interaction synonymous with the music / sound department) and above all the media management is a great role and just that there's some big differences.


These differences are evaluated for quality? The whole accounting Page can still differ more than skin deep. Of course, an Avid editors to know how he must organize his projects, that is his job. And likewise with other systems. At the appearance of the finished film, that can not only affect if the person does a bad job.


Reply JossJoss5000:

Well, light works or not, the winners for best editing have been working with Final Cut Pro (plus a bissl Premiere and AfterFX).

But only because of hard cuts - this is an interesting video, as AfterFX was used for Conforming and how to "improve" is still behind the representational services can:

http://www.adobe.com/products/after effects / customers /

For more information and links available here, good reading:




Reply Valentino:

In principle, there should be no preference with which program I cut while the cutter, it's made of and can deliver a good result.

In the top advertising videos of Adobe is simply shown only that something is synonymous with holding AfterFX and Final Cut Pro, but despite the constant of Avid NLE is still the most widely used by professional editors.
The effects shown here, I have been making in the MC in a few minutes without which I would need AfterFX for it.
In Final Cut Pro editing software Avid is a long way behind in terms of such simple compositing. The sheer number of effects, and the title tool and the tracking function can be found in Final Cut Pro still does not.
Especially when a guy falls immediately whether with Final Cut Pro or another program has worked. MOV as a container format and the associated Gama problem we're only talking about actually not s.zur. And there is MXF is simply the better choice, I think there zBsden P2 Workflow: HXP171 Connect cut, and play without me only one video of have copied the P2 card or previously converted into a different container format needed.

Sometimes it is so completely synonymous natural features such as front and back the image with the arrow keys, which does not work for AfterFX for some reason.


Reply freezer:

"Valentino" wrote:
In Final Cut Pro editing software Avid is a long way behind in terms of such simple compositing. The sheer number of effects, and the title tool and the tracking function can be found in Final Cut Pro still does not.

What do you mean with easy compositing? Is it in Final Cut Pro.
Tracking with BorisFX. Titles with Motion. Super Templates to operate quickly and easily.
What does not fit in the credits? Final Cut Pro to fit but even the auto scroll speed, so no flicker ensteht.
"Valentino" wrote:
MOV as a container format and the associated Gama problem we're only talking about actually not s.zur.
The problem you only if you are not familiar with the workflow. However annoying it is true!
"Valentino" wrote:
And there is MXF is simply the better choice, I think there zBsden P2 workflow:
Agreement!
Sometimes it is so completely synonymous natural features such as
"Valentino" wrote:
Trick mode before and Back with the arrow keys, which does not work for AfterFX for some reason.
Go with Picture-In / Picture-down buttons, as the arrow keys are otherwise occupied.


Reply dustdancer:

@ Valentino:
I want to start any flame war, but maybe you should have only a wafer-synonymous of foreboding about the tools, of which one writes ...
Quote:
Sometimes it is so completely synonymous natural features such as front and back the image with the arrow keys, which does not work for AfterFX for some reason.

pgn ever with up / down tried? But first a little trash talk ...
Most errors are sitting in front of the computer time ...


Reply Valentino:

@ Freezer
Boris Effects not cost money again? When the MC are already included.
Final Cut Pro itself can not all, but containing the additional Programs of Final Cut Pro Studio, but why is this the way?
As I said, the MC provides all in one program.

@ Dustdancer
Talking with garbage that has more to do less, I'm used to it simply as MC Used with the arrow keys to jump in front and back picture.
This works fine with Final Cut Pro to believe even in Premiere are the keys so busy, why not AfterFX?
That is when the Avid keyboard can prove just as one is funny and can then take his own Benutzterprofil everywhere is just a wonderful thing that is missing one or the other editing software.


Reply NEEL:

Let 's not so bad for Final Cut. After all, there are a few movies, which are cut with it. This may be of Magix not maintain itself. Also sees a Mac and send out when necessary to make the cutter pretty synonymous.

Light Works the other hand seems to be a good addition in a professional environment to Avid to be (and vice versa). However, the entries in the vote Slashcam Lightworks forum yet confident. is probably more what the ever häufger occurring cross between editors and System Admins ...:)


Reply Axel:

"Neel" wrote:
Let 's not so bad for Final Cut. After all, there are a few movies, which are cut with it. This may be of Magix not maintain itself. Also sees a Mac and send out when necessary to make the cutter pretty synonymous.)


Such pseudo-superior Proverbs, where it was not an editing program, but the average award as a creative performance call types such as vfxheini on the plan that you have earned then synonymous. Childish obstinacy, as if about to you about agreeable and familiar keyboard layout says something about the professionalism.
And I do not give Oscars to what is, for example, the Camera for Oscar Inception? But here None need patronizing Final Cut Pro to spare because of this - and not AVID - brought the average Oscar.


Reply freezer:

@ Valentino

IN AE used the arrow keys to move in a plane XY. This requires 4 keys, ergo it is a logical function on the arrow keys, lay spread than on any other buttons.
The same function, the arrow keys is the way in Photoshop and AE as a sort of Photoshop for film, this assignment was quite consistent - the two share as synonymous many other shortcuts.

If it bothers you, you can change the key bindings to your liking.

However, the default assignment in AE is very complex - see Help -> Keyboard shortcuts.

You can show the way, synonymous in Premiere your keyboard as you want, save the settings and take.


Reply Mantas:

"Jott" wrote:
A feature film consists almost exclusively of hard cuts - and that creates really any NLE. To discuss which film with which product was cut - or even to advertise it - is profoundly ridiculous.


hm ne ne ne, a film is long, here comes s.ende many things together to force the program to its knees.


Reply NEEL:

"Axel" wrote:

Such pseudo-superior Proverbs, where it was not an editing program, but the average award as a creative performance call types such as vfxheini on the plan that you have earned then synonymous.


I admit I was bored ... Sorry for that :-)


Reply markus2h:

And that is no preference as that?


Reply soan:

"Valentino" wrote:

The effects shown here, I have been making in the MC in a few minutes without which I would need AfterFX for it.


I cut with Avid for years in the television sector and the limited options of the hate Avid Composer. The effects are complex, each with a bit more effects Pinnefitz / Videospurem needs to be rendered and for really good effects will not be around plug-ins.

All in all, the hard Avid editing software - you can achieve more synonymous only indirectly and with complicated tricks


Reply nicecam:

I found the post of NEEL quite appropriate. Thanks for the mention of MAGIX :-)



Apple Final Cut Pro

NTSC Aufnamen with NTSC Camera with Media Composer or Final Cut Pro 4 capture
Final Cut + Intensity = no 1080 24p on the preview
CoreMeltFREE: 33 free plugins for Final Cut Pro, Motion and AFX
Motion JPEG with Final Cut Pro or CS5?
Final Cut Pro and Premiere OSX machine to cut budget price
Once again the WorkflowCanon5D and Final Cut ...
AVCHD vs. Motion JPEG? (Mac / Final Cut)
workflow for proxies 5DMII or 7D or 550D Final Cut
Final Cut suddenly choppy?
Panasonic Plug-in for Final Cut
How much memory is max. support of Final Cut?
Final Cut and NAB2011?
Final Cut 6 to Edius
MacPro 1.1 Final Cut system load question
Sound in the whole sequence to make quieter Final Cut Pro
Different FPS in Final Cut Pro
Exchange of Apple to Windows or Final Cut to Premiere
Final Cut. S.PC edit mov
The King's Speech - cut with Avid or Final Cut?
VOB files in Final Cut editing. Respectively. DVD rip?


Avid

Avid Studio or MAGIX Video deluxe 17 Premium
Avid Media Composer: Window Jump (4 monitors)
Avid MC von5.1 update to 5.5 free?
Avid After Effects Project with degrees such as (without loss) is that possible?
The King's Speech - cut with Avid or Final Cut?
Avid Xpress Pro does not cut.
Avid Media Composer is 5.5, NewsCutter and Symphony 9.5 5.5 before
Avid Composer Sound Only no Picture
Newcomers: Avid Studio 1.0 - Avid Studio?
Avid Liquid successor - Nextgen?
PluralEyes for Avid Media Composer
AVID - ONLY Alpha channel on XDCAM
Vegas, Avid and the reality (Sandy Bride Core i7 2600)
AVID - 8bit and 10bit mixing
Avid Media Comps - opportunities to create Project?
How EOS convert to Avid DNxHD
Avid DVD by Sonic
JVC GZ-HM1 movies into Avid Media Composer?
AVID MC5 GTX graphics cards to Quadro hack?
Avid MC v5 + Quad Core AMD, only 25% capacity and playing it?


Avid Xpress Pro

Avid Studio or MAGIX Video deluxe 17 Premium
Avid Media Composer: Window Jump (4 monitors)
Avid MC von5.1 update to 5.5 free?
Avid After Effects Project with degrees such as (without loss) is that possible?
The King's Speech - cut with Avid or Final Cut?
Avid Xpress Pro does not cut.
Avid Composer Sound Only no Picture
Avid Media Composer is 5.5, NewsCutter and Symphony 9.5 5.5 before
Newcomers: Avid Studio 1.0 - Avid Studio?
Avid Liquid successor - Nextgen?
PluralEyes for Avid Media Composer
AVID - ONLY Alpha channel on XDCAM
Vegas, Avid and the reality (Sandy Bride Core i7 2600)
AVID - 8bit and 10bit mixing
Avid Media Comps - opportunities to create Project?
How EOS convert to Avid DNxHD
Avid DVD by Sonic
JVC GZ-HM1 movies into Avid Media Composer?
AVID MC5 GTX graphics cards to Quadro hack?
Avid MC v5 + Quad Core AMD, only 25% capacity and playing it?

















more topics:
1080i
1080p
1394
16:9
24p
25p
35mm
3D
50i
720p
8mm
AFX
AVCHD
AVI
Ac3
Adapter
Adobe After Effects
Adobe Encore DVD
Adobe Premiere Elements
Adobe Premiere Pro
After effects
Ahead Nero
Apple
Apple DVD Studio Pro
Apple Final Cut Pro
Apple iMovie
Audio
Avid
Avid Media Composer
Avid Xpress Pro
Band
Batterie
Battery
Blender
Blu-ray
Bluray
Book
CCD
CMOS
CPU
Camcorder
Camera
Canon
Canon 5D
Canon EOS
Canon EOS 5D MKII
Canon HV10
Canon HV20
Canon HV30
Canon XH A1
Canon XH-A1
Canon XL H1
Canon XL1
Canopus
Canopus Edius
Canopus ProCoder
Capture
Capturing
Clip
Clips
Codecs
Compression
Computer
Converter
CyberLink PowerDirector
DSLR
DV
DV-IN
DVB
DVB-S
DVB-T
DVCPRO
DVD Burner
DVD-Player
DVD-lab
Dazzle
Digibeta
Digicam
Director
DivX
Divx
Dolby
Download
EX3
Editing
Effekte
Encoder
Encoding
Export
FLV
Festivals
Field
File
Files
Film
Filmlook
Filmmaker
Filter
Final Cut
Final Cut Pro
Firewire
Flash
Flycam
Footage
Formate
Formats
Forum
Frame
Frames
Freeware
FullHD
GEMA
Gain
Glidecam
H.264
HDD
HDMI
HDTV
HDV
Headphones
Hi8
IPhone
Intel
Interlace
Interview
JVC
Keying
LANC
Lens
Lenses
Light
Lighting
Linux
Liquid
Lowlight
Lumix
MAGIX video deLuxe
MP4
MPEG
MPEG-2
MPEG-4
Mac
Matrox
Maxon CINEMA 4D
Media Player
Medion
Mic
Microphone
Microsoft Movie Maker
MiniDV
Mixer
Monitor
Mov
Movie
Mp3
Mpeg2
Mpeg4
NTSC
News
Nikon
Notebook
P2
PAL
PC
Panasonic
Panasonic AG-HVX200
Photoshop
Pinnacle
Pinnacle Studio
Pixel
Player
Plugins
Premiere
Projector
Quicktime
RAID
Recorder
Red
Remote Control
Resolution
Review
S-Video
SAT
SDI
SVCD
Samsung
Sanyo
Scart
Script
Sennheiser
Shake
Shoot
Shooting
Slideshow
Sony
Sony Vegas Movie Studio
Sony Vegas Video
Sony XDCAM PMW EX1
Sound
Soundtrack
Speaker
Spot
Steadicams
Still
Still Image
Streaming
TMPGEnc
TV
Tape
Test
Tips
Ton
Track
Tripod
Tutorial
Tutorials
USB
Ulead MediaStudio
Ulead VideoStudio
Update
VCD/DVD
VCR
VCRs
VGA
VHS
Vegas
Video DSLR
Video Editing
Video8
Virtual Dub
VirtualDub
Vista
White balance
Windows
Windows Media
Windows media
Wmv
XDCAM
XL1S
Xacti
Xlr
Xvid
YUV
YouTube

Sonstige

Featuresschraeg
slashCAM
slashCAM
News
HD Camcorder database
One-on-One Cam comparison
About our tests
About us


update am 6.April 2011 - 09:35
slashCAM ist ein Projekt der channelunit GmbH
*Datenschutzhinweis*