Frage von julell:
Hello,
Have already read all kinds, but it now dare to look a new thread aufzumachen ...
I have a fairly large amount of MiniDV footage - about 17 total hours! - All on DVD to be archived. It is a conference recording, dhvsTalking Heads without major changes in the Picture. The aim of the DVD (s) is that our course participants to the talks s.PC home TV or hear them again after. So, broadly compatible, still in tolerable quality view, however, as few DVDs as possible fit.
The film was shot with a Panasonic 3CCP because of a defect, but the quality is rather bad (many dropouts, Asynchronität, blur). I've edited it into FinalCut Express HD 3.5.1, iDVD authoring will happen.
Have now a 55-minute sequence with following settings exported: Quicktime H.264 conversion, frame rate 25 fps, keyframe auto, data rate is limited to 4000 kbit / s, optimized for CD / DVD-Rom, image size 321 x 241 (compression-specific).
The result after about 4 hours calculation is 2.17 GB in size, full-bitrate 5589, sound perfect, the picture quality still handsome, in the plain areas of the image but clearly pixilated.
Questions:
- Can I get any useful settings suggest that the better quality but the file does not make much larger?
- Are the settings for TV and PC playback for?
- Would it be better in general, only in good quality from FCE to export and then again for the DVD to be compressed? If yes with what program?
- Question synonymous: better-DVD SL or DL DVD-choose? As far as I know it's a balancing storage capacity vs. higher. better compatibility with players?
Schonmal very sincere thanks for your help!
Juliane
Antwort von jazzy_d:
Although I have no MAC, but video on DVD for the TV is still mpeg2 with 720x576 or something like that.
The living room player with QT h.264 can not start very well but with SL-and DL-DVD.
The best way is to convert as little as possible (because there is always tainted with the loss). You can do everything directly s.Timeline in virtually all exports. So always be the original source material directly from the timeline in the appropriate format to export.
Antwort von tommyb:
If people all must have compatible as possible (ie synonymous s.normalen should look), then you come to MPEG2 with 352x288 pixels resolution as a non-round.
If you have stereo audio on leaves and with 128kbit codierst, would you all 17 hours on a DL DVD can get with just 980kbit / s for video (or even two normal DVDs with the same bitrate). In order to achieve maximum compression you can be reached on the Picture to deinterlace 25p (for the export or the code as you want).
h264 is like I said NOT compatible with standard DVD players.
Image size 321 x 241 (compression-specific) Compression must be specific as synonymous Height Width of the image divisible by 16:
Antwort von julell:
If you have stereo audio on leaves and with 128kbit codierst, would you all 17 hours on a DL DVD can get with just 980kbit / s for video (or even two normal DVDs with the same bitrate).
oh wow ... remains because of the building was still visible left?
try ...
Antwort von Alan Smithee:
iDVD encodes the movies themselves
always in MPEG-2 for DVD, so can you advice so far forget!
The only possibility to influence the film length, the quality settings in iDVD, not "Best Quality" option, but "Best Performance" - then you need to look at how much space the movie on the DVD and used the movie in FCE accordingly extended.
In order to avoid unnecessary transcoding, you should not use QuickTime Conversion ... "but" File -> Export -> QuickTime Movie ... "option. Since you have the opportunity synonymous, chapter markers for iDVD with exporting.
Antwort von julell:
[/ quote] iDVD encoded the movies themselves
always in MPEG-2 for the DVD [/ quote]
Fact. habs now synonymous noticed
[/ quote] In order to avoid unnecessary transcoding, you should not use QuickTime Conversion ... "but" File -> Export -> QuickTime Movie ... "option. Since you have the opportunity synonymous, chapter markers for iDVD with exporting. [/ Quote]
understood. yet again the naive question: is there any possibility, the videos somehow "less" to export (via quicktime conversion, such as animation, photo-jpeg, etc?) before they are encoded in mpeg2, so more easily fits on a DVD ? when exporting as a quicktime movie I only get about an hour on DVD ... clearly, the quality is top, but I would like people but to slightly less than 17 discs in the hand press ...
regards
Antwort von Alan Smithee:
With iDVD, there is no other option. Any previously recode is counterproductive because it only ensures that the quality deteriorated.
For your problem I really see only 2 solutions:
1) with the entire Final Cut Studio makes (+ Compressor DVD Studio Pro). As you can determine how the MPEG2 files on the DVD are compressed.
2) The whole with a PC do. What opportunities are there, I do not - but MPEG2 files from the editing program to create and then with a DVD authoring program seems to be used because the usual way.
or Plan B:
Pure data-DVDs, which are not in any playable. As example, you could compress with DivX, which can be at least a couple of play. Who such a player has to be then just look on the PC.
Antwort von julell:
Well ... Thanks in any case for your answers!
