Frage von MB1983k:
Hello,
Unfortunately, it is difficult for me on the internet properly meaningful comparisons of the following test to get your camcorder. Therefore I ask here to purchase advice. What are the advantages and disadvantages of the following camcorders:
Samsung VP-DC171W
Hitachi DZ-GX5020E
Panasonic VDR-S D160EG
Hitachi DZ-BX35E
Hitachi DZ-MV780E
SonyDCR-DVD105E
Canon DC210
Panasonic VDR-S D220EG
Canon DC220
Canon DC100
Hitachi DZ-GX5100E
From everything I've read so far, I would have the Hitachi DZ-GX5100E quite well, but my knowledge in this area is quite limited.
Please simply to gather views on the camcorder and to their respective tips.
Antwort von Bernd E.:
Please simply to gather views on the camcorder and to their respective tips. From my own experience I can say nothing, because I did not do DVD camcorder would like to, but below
www.camcorderinfo.com/d/Reviews&level_b=Camcorders&level_c=DVD.htm
You can find quite detailed test reports of a row of your candidate (although in the U.S. NTSC version, but not for the next comparison is of concern).
Gruß Bernd E.
Antwort von levis0208:
Thank you - I have looked at those reports and then reports of other pages and read through all always say something else - it can be somehow difficult to form an opinion.
If someone has experience with this DVD camcorder, then please briefly the pros and cons list.
Or just your opinion gem. the technical data of the devices to post ...
Antwort von dan1el:
Or let's say this:
Which of the above is better than the SonyDCR-HC23
Antwort von dan1el:
So, I have now created a ranking, starting with the best of the worst - at least I'll believe that this ranking would look like. This ranking, I purely from my own thoughts gem. the data and the few available test reports.
I urge anyone who thinks that this ranking is not right for correction.
1. Hitachi DZ-GX5100E
2. Panasonic VDR-S D220EG
3. Hitachi DZ-MV780E
4. Canon DC220
5. Canon DC210
6. Canon DC100
7. Panasonic VDR-S D160EG
8. Hitachi DZ-BX35E
9. Hitachi DZ-GX5020E
10. SonyDCR-DVD105E
11. Samsung VP-DC171W
Antwort von Bernd E.:
I urge anyone who thinks that this ranking is not right for correction. Silence can often be interpreted as consent, but if you rather not get answers, then this may be because not too many people experience with these devices have - especially what Hitachi is concerned. While reading the numerous posts relating to DVD camcorders here in the forum you will be noticed that the storage media more frustration than joy which has caused, which - to some ill-advised or wrong - a DVD camcorder have increased. My tip would be synonymous MiniDV instead, but if you deliberately set on DVD, then I would simply point s.deiner the camcorder in the mail order, you personally and s.besten gives him a good feeling for free (incl. Postprocessing of the images s.PC) that keep it within 14 days of return can give.
Gruß Bernd E.
Antwort von dan1el:
This advice is so synonymous to me here - I would, in principle, yes, the videos are no longer synonymous großartig really edit it immediately in a fairly good quality (for an amateur) can watch.
Mir, it is quite aware that I am because of the MiniDV system to record more details - but I would then return only those synonymous editing without burning to a DVD and this is quite a chore.
And I think to me anyway, that a DVD camcorder that can meet needs perfectly - and if he s.Schluß at least the same quality in Sound and Picture is as SonyDCR-HC23E, I am very satisfied.
But unfortunately I have to the above thoughts, or the models have not really receive feedback and thus I am still quite heavy at about what I should do.
Only what I have found is 300, - MiniDV camcorder is always better than a 300, - DVD camcorder, this is correct? (as I said, I am really from zero in this field)
Antwort von Daigoro:
Mir, it is quite aware that I am because of the MiniDV system to record more details - but I would then return only those synonymous editing without burning to a DVD and this is quite a chore.
Muehsam?
Read here the times relating to DVD camcorder and then by überleg nachmal what is really Muehsam:
http://www.videoaktiv.de/content/view/211/45/
Antwort von dan1el:
Ok - welcome to the world of DVDs - and now where is the problem? The blanks with different I know - just what brings me the MiniDV system when I first 2 hours movie on the PC to play (you know what 2 hours required) for the whole only to a DVD to burn ....
And again the question:
I notice these processes s.Ende quality differences between a 300, - MiniDV camcorder or a 300, - DVD Camcorders
Antwort von dan1el:
I notice these processes s.Ende quality differences between a 300, - MiniDV camcorder or a 300, - DVD Camcorders Since both anyway just gather dust in the cupboard will you can say with certainty: No, you will not notice differences in quality.
Antwort von Quadruplex:
And if it's necessarily because a DVD camcorder to be, I would look at video in the active list / Camcorderdatenbak and then look for the kiosk slippers - to test these things regularly.
Antwort von dan1el:
What are these statements again - I should have liked to here more qualified statements in such a forum is expected - is this really the quality of this forum - I want the camcorder naturally synonymous benefit - for example: to shoot - when I do get dusty, other objects ...
Antwort von dan1el:
And if it's necessarily because a DVD camcorder to be, I would look at video in the active list / Camcorderdatenbak and then look for the kiosk slippers - to test these things regularly. OK - and I notice the difference between a DVD and MiniDV camcorders in the same price class ........
Antwort von dan1el:
And if it's necessarily because a DVD camcorder to be, I would look at video in the active list / Camcorderdatenbak and then look for the kiosk slippers - to test these things regularly. In any event, times, thank you for the tip with video active:
According to the list should be yes, the Panasonic VDR-D220 is much better than the SonyDCR-HC23 (which is not in the list, however, is the HC27 so synonymous much worse)?
Antwort von Markus73:
According to the list should be yes, the Panasonic VDR-D220 is much better than the SonyDCR-HC23 (which is not in the list, however, is the HC27 so synonymous much worse)? Yes, the Panasonics supply in the beginners class colors much better than the "small" Sony. Search times you test the image out of HC23: I think it's pretty bad, both of sharpness as synonymous (mostly) what the colors are concerned.
Gruß,
Markus
Antwort von Daigoro:
just what brings me the MiniDV system when I first 2 hours movie on the PC to play (you know what 2 hours required) for the whole only to a DVD to burn ....
It brings you:
- Inexpensive, relatively insensitive (compared to DVDs, especially the double-sided), 'future proof' and easily archived media
- 25 Mbps data rate over 90 full minute
- A source in much high quality video format
- Rapid change without media format or finalize
- Wide and supported by cutting Effect Programs
And since you do not sit and Next to the capturn images mitzaehlen need, whether the trial isses capturn 60 minutes or 20 hours.
The time you spend with the processing MUST is probably still below what you see on your format or finalize the DVD camcorder wait while you do not film it.
OK - and I notice the difference between a DVD and MiniDV camcorders in the same price class ........ How do you want to reference material without having to remember a difference?
There are people who think their cell phones makes' super videos.
Antwort von dan1el:
Is the Picture of the Panasonic synonymous likes me better ...
According to the list should be yes, the Panasonic VDR-D220 is much better than the SonyDCR-HC23 (which is not in the list, however, is the HC27 so synonymous much worse)?
Yes, the Panasonics supply in the beginners class colors much better than the "small" Sony. Search times you test the image out of HC23: I think it's pretty bad, both of sharpness as synonymous (mostly) what the colors are concerned.
Gruß,
Markus
Antwort von Jan:
I hope you know the abundant synonymous disadvantages of DVD camcorders?
Of the 18 min recording time (Panasonic) in best quality with the use of a 30 min DVD actually says what synonymous None, yes there are double (36 min), which are unfortunately only up to above and described in Wenden's almost impossible not to beta chen. And the actual models DL - are the only non-rewritable and 3-5x as expensive as some 30s.
There are quite a few people synonymous with the VR or Video mode (DVD - RW) clear consumer favorite program Magix 2006 / 2007 can not zb VRO files (VR) process, older programs are not only legally, they've got massive problems with the Dolby Digital Sound (AC 3) the
DVD models, Sonyhat among even the top model mixed 5.1 sound.
From Finalize (ca 10 min) is synonymous told nothing in advance, which is often synonymous not a power that is needed.
And now comes the hammer, the old mini-DV will live longer than the old DVD Camcorder Group, Hitachi last week Blue Ray DVD camcorder for 2008 prospect. This is a Blue Ray Sonygarantiert developers are not synonymous and can sit 8 cm BD camcorder on the market pose .....
Hitachi is already an innovative company, one should know, however, not without reason produced for some time Panasonic DVD camcorder prefer their own and can not as it used to manufacture of Hitachi.
Ok we come back relating to what type of DVD Player & Recorder do you have?
If you a short-editing software included important - then Panasonic would be the wrong company, because until the 2007 when the VDR 310 sowas supplied has no VDR 100,150,160,220. If you want a model with the supplied Charger favorable external battery and choice, a good manual exposure controls (shutter, aperture / gain) then you're in the right place Pana. Do you have a camera with a "good" night program in motion - then Sony.
Then do you like the Sony touch screen, you'll get the original battery synonymous expensive to buy? - Unfortunately the Sonyhat Batteries FH 2007 at the market, which at the moment is still very difficult to be copied.
For the simple would be my order:
VDR 220, DVD 106, DC 210th
VAD has the seats 2 and 3 swapped, the Sony but of dignity, I better appreciate the possibilities, including an easy target but Schnittprogamm & supplied USB cable, NightShot (WERS needs) and a very good wide-angle (opposite of DC 210).
The DVD camcorder is nothing more effective with MiniDV camcorders are seen in the VAD tests SonyDVD 106 and SonyHC 37 - identical - both 52 points, Extremo filmmakers may see at fast pans and many details still smaller advantages in MiniDV.
For Panasonic DVD Player & Recorder (with you at home) is the very simple choice - the DVD RAM, you will have many advantages to other companies (Hitachi course synonymous) - does not finalize, and only one mode in the VR, cut into the Camera , create playlists, etc. of the VDR would be 220 The Number 1 ...
And please do not mixing a wild, a list of good 10 DVD camcorders (Initial & megapixel photo etc) of 2006 & 2007, then usually something like this just out.
The websites in the published reports are often for Katz, because very often the only user's own Camera & knows just purchased, rarely is more synonymous as background knowledge, or even important differences between the models - a few of those of like I just talked did.
VG
Jan
